Monsanto ‘bullied scientists’ and hid weedkiller cancer risk, lawyer tells court

As ill California mans landmark case begins, attorney attacks Roundup makers response to researchers findings


Monsanto has long worked to bully scientists and suppress evidence of the cancer risks of its popular weedkiller, a lawyer argued on Monday in a landmark lawsuit against the global chemical corporation.

Monsanto has specifically gone out of its way to bully and to fight independent researchers, said the attorney Brent Wisner, who presented internal Monsanto emails that he said showed how the agrochemical company rejected critical research and expert warnings over the years while pursuing and helping to write favorable analyses of their products. They fought science.

Recommended For You

Reddule Agency

Agency Reseller Special Upgrade of Reddule

PLR Firesale - Upsell Pack

Complete PLR resell opportunity - (3 Upgrade Product are included with sales material )

ThemeMaker Live VIP Masterclass Split Pay

EXCLUSIVE 4 Week LIVE VIP Masterclass. Ask Me Questions, Exclusive Tips and Watch Me Build Sites With You In This Live Masterclass!

Wisner, who spoke inside a crowded San Francisco courtroom, is representing DeWayne Johnson, known also as Lee, a California man whose cancer has spread through his body. The father of three and former school groundskeeper, who doctors say may have just months to live, is the first person to take Monsanto to trial over allegations that the chemical sold under the Roundup brand is linked to cancer. Thousands have made similar legal claims across the US.

In his opening remarks, the Monsanto lawyer George Lombardi alleged that the body of research over the years was on the companys side: The scientific evidence is overwhelming that glyphosate-based products do not cause cancer and did not cause Mr Johnsons cancer.

The case is significant in part because the judge has allowed Johnsons lawyers to present scientific arguments. The suit centers on glyphosate, the worlds most widely used herbicide, which Monsanto began marketing as Roundup in 1974, presenting it as a technological breakthrough that could kill almost every weed without harming humans or the environment.

Over the years, however, studies have suggested otherwise, and in 2015, the World Health Organizations international agency for research on cancer (IARC) classified glyphosate as probably carcinogenic to humans.

Roundup products are registered in 130 countries and approved for use on more than 100 crops, and glyphosate has been found in food, a variety of water sources, and the urine of agricultural workers and others. A number of countries have policies banning or restricting the sale and use of glyphosate.

Johnson worked as a groundskeeper for a the school district in Benicia, just north of San Francisco, and was responsible for applying Roundup. Lawyers showed the jury photos of lesions and rashes on Johnsons skin after he was regularly exposed to the chemical and was eventually diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) in 2014, at age 42.

Recommended For You

WP Conversion Boost Agency License

Instantly boost conversion with super targeted pages.


100% automated video marketing.Get automated content Get automated traffic Get automated list building Get automated social followers Get automated PROFITSAll using the power of VIDEO

MailPrimo Pro

World's No.1 and Most Powerful Cloud Based Email Marketing Software to STOP Losing Leads, STOP Paying Heavy Monthly Fees and Generate More Leads, Get Better Delivery, More Opens and Clicks completely hassle free...

The simple fact is hes going to die. Its just a matter of time, Wisner said in court, as Johnson lowered his head and his wife cried in the seat next to him. Between now and then, its just nothing but pain.

Wisner, who said the trial would include commentary from 10 current or former Monsanto employees, also read aloud internal corporate documents obtained during the case. In response to one critical study about glyphosate exposure, Donna Farmer, product protection lead, wrote in an email: How do we combat this?

Wisner also referenced an email from Farmer in which she gave colleagues guidance on how they could publicly talk about science, writing: You cannot say that Roundup does not cause cancer. The Monsanto lawyer later said this comment had been taken out of context and presented in a misleading way.

A strategic corporate document also revealed Monsantos public relations plan to orchestrate outcry in advance of the IARC glyphosate classification, Wisner told the jury.

Wisner further cited Monsanto emails from decades prior, in which the company was working with a genotoxicity expert who reviewed a series of 1990s studies. He raised concerns about Roundup impacts on humans and suggested further areas of research. After the experts analyses, Monsanto representatives began considering finding a different expert and also started working on a press statement saying the product carried no risk, according to Johnsons lawyer.

Wisner also read documents that he said showed how Monsanto strategized plans to ghostwrite favorable research.

Monsanto has continued to assert that its herbicide is safe, a claim that Johnsons legal team is challenging, arguing that scientific fraud has contributed to Roundup marketing.

Lombardi, the Monsanto lawyer, argued that Johnsons lawyers were cherrypicking studies that did not provide a full picture, repeatedly pointed to Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) findings approving the use of glyphosate, and argued that the plaintiffs were overstating the significance of IARCs conclusions. He also said Monsanto had been open about its involvement in research, adding: Testing has been done by independent scientists, by university scientists, by government scientists.

Recommended For You

Lifetime Stock Video Monthly

Lifetime access to Lifetime Stock Video including 1,000 4K and HD video backgrounds and footages.

Timothy Litzenburg, one of Johnsons lawyers, called his client incredibly brave in an interview with the Guardian before trial, adding: Whatever happens his sons will get to know that their dad was brave enough to go up against Monsanto completely alone, and first, before he died.

In addition to financial compensation, a verdict in Johnsons favor would say that his life is worth something, Litzenburg added.

Regardless of the outcome, the attorney said, so much of what Monsanto has worked to keep secret is coming out.

Original Article : HERE ; This post was curated & posted using : RealSpecific

Thank you for taking the time to read our article.

If you enjoyed our content, we'd really appreciate some "love" with a share or two.

And ... Don't forget to have fun!

Recommended Products

Clickopia Unlimited (Unlimited clicks/mo.)

Clickopia Unlimited Click Tracking Service - Monthly service with a one-time price. Track unlimited links for up unlimited clicks per month.

TigerPress Volume 8

Premium one of a kind wordpress themes that do all the onpage seo for you including image seo, with TigerPress themes you can also generate an unlimited amount of geo targeted landing pages in any language.

Audioflow OTO1

Make videos like the PRO's with the most advanced audio solution for video creators.

Leave a Reply